HELP! What to choose

I would say mugwort based like I’m from mugwort essence. But personally I don’t do well with it, but my friend did get great result. In my opinion, if u have problem with irritation and skin barrier, toner doesn’t do much besides hydrates, so maybe it’s better to invest in serum, ampoule and any type of concentrated.

I would vote on the Beplain toner just because products for dry skin types like the other toner, tend to include some exfoliating ingredients which might be too much for a broken skin barrier. The Beplain one has chamomile to soothe and ceramides which are great for rebuilding that barrier.

I haven't try the beplain but i have try the anua toner. So far i like anua toner, tte texture very watery and its soothing and calming. I always use when i have exfoliate my skin for calming the tingling sensation.

I’ve only tried the anua toner, and I think it’s a product with great soothing and calming abilities. But the thing is, when I used it on the first few days my skin barrier was damaged, it did sting a little so I’m not sure if it’ll be the right product for the healing process although the ingredients are pretty clean.

I wish I had tried these products so I could give you a solid answer, but I know heartleaf is more likely to cause allergic reactions than chamomile, so maybe the chamomile will be best to try? I personally prefer cica or centella when my skin is angry. I find it the most effective, especially when combined with camellia sinensis (green tea). If you find those products aren't working, I highly recommend some of these!