-It oxidized. The shade became several shades darker both on swatches and on my lips
-Shades are NOT true to online swatches. Rose in Mind was advertised as a neutral shade to me but it was way warmer in reality

-It was very glossy and lightweight!!!
-You don’t have to wait for a glossy ‘film’ to form like other glossy products
-It stains really well!
-It doesnt have a light base, so it didn’t look weird on my pigmented lips

-drying on my lips
-color didn’t match my skin tone (23-25 east asian skin)
-wasn’t in love with the applicator, was small and felt flimsy

-very easy to put on, matte
-not OVERTLY drying
-wide range of colors
-good amount for price

-very white base, even the browns look chalky when i swatch them (do NOT recommend for darker skin tones—im around a 23-25)
-lots of fallout with a brush, i recommend fingers
-a lot of the colors, especially the browns look very similar on ME
-the packaging is sort of flimsy

-great for highlighting+aegyosal
-feels very buttery, and soft
-works well with both fingers and a brush
-the colors are very cohesive! 
-the shimmers are gorgeous!!!

-it’s too thin. the formula feels nonexistent on my lips and it has NO lasting formula because of how thin it is
-it wasn’t hydrating. i just think for the inflated price on amazon, i expect more
-i don’t love the applicator with this formula. i think the applicator spreads the gloss really thin which adds on to the already thin and slipping off my lips formula
—-i also personally prefer a doe foot because i love the way it hugs my lips, which this applicator doesn’t because it’s straight

-glossy, nonsticky
-minty tingle (nonpainful)
-makes my lips look plump 
-doesn’t feel heavy on lips
-slight sparkles!
-the silicon tip is very hygienic!
-the packaging>>>

-squeeze applicator. i think it just lessens the overall experience and also stains my fingers/hand whenever i use it
-when i use it on the lips, it feels almost oily? in the fact that it sits on top of my lips and doesn’t hydrate
-accentuates cracks in lips 

-PIGMENTED
-gorgeous color
-pretty on lip and cheeks
-shades true to swatches
-good amount of product
-stains (pro or con)

kathtea