My review us for the original version of this product, which was reformulated last year. I bought thus on sale at Sephora in late 2019, during a sale. It had no fragrance and I thought it did a great job removing mascara and eye makeup. It removed without any rubbing of tge eye area. It is similar to a micellar water and could be used as a makeup remover, but I just used it for eye makeup. It took me about a year to finish (PAO is 12 months). I would not repurchase though as it is expensive and I understand the current version slso has fragrance.