Maybe because the tone range is limited, so it doesnt match my skin.. It makes me grey-skinned. My skin is almost the color of molasses sugar, or medium tanned. So, this is not the product for me or for those with oily skin unless you are obsessed with having shiny skin. Smells like powder foundation and it transfers. If i put this on the area under my eye, over time it fills my under eyeline and looks really unflattering.