This isn't a bad mascata at all. I loved it at first actually. At first it seemed like more of a wet formula and it gave me great length. However after the 3rd of 4th time I used it ,it had dried up more and gave me clumpy lashes with little length. I dont think it is worth a second purchase from me if I get only 2 good used out of it. However if you don't mind mascaras not giving much length and like a clumppier lash then j think you'd like this. It wasn't as hard to get off as people make it seem but I also use a oil cleanser when wearing makeup.