Didn't completely remove makeup. It needs to be used as a first step only followed up by a second cleanser. Disposable wipes are terribly wasteful and bad for the environment. Plus wipes are supposed to be a hassle free, water splashing free way of getting gunk off the face. At least it is in my mind. So having to wash my face anyway after using this defeats the purpose. But of all affordable makeup wipes, this beats the rest (Nivea, Sephora, Garnier etc).