Benton has provided Honest Black Eyelash Serum to me for review purposes.
I used the Beagle Freedom Project Cruelty Cutter app and learned Benton Honest Black Eyelash Serum is cruelty free. Thank you, Benton, for being cruelty free and not testing your products on animals.
The serum does not smudge or flake after application.
In the photos, my eyelashes on my left eye do not have serum on them, and my eyelashes on my right eye have two coats of serum on them.
The serum is easy to remove with lukewarm water; there is no need to use cleansing oil.