Mugwort VS Centella | Ingredients

Ingredients

Patwreckkk user profile picture

Patwreckkk

Oily/Sensitive

dot3,377 Views

Mugwort VS Centella

I can't decide which one to pick. First of all, Mugwort is not a famous ingredient at all compared to the rising celebrity in skin care, Centella. In line with the recent post of Picky Team of Toners, Madagascar is surely the most picked and most upvotes. So here's my thought, If the Madagascar toner claims that it's a 100 percent Centella, doesn't most Korean products now have all Centella in it? On the other hand, I'm From's Essence is a novel contender which is almost a pure Mugwort. Dear Picky members, which one proves it's claimed benefits at all? P.S. Im planning to add either to my routine.
Madagascar Centella Toning Toner

SKIN1004
Madagascar Centella Toning Toner

star rating

4.5

(1372)

favorite

1596

Mugwort Essence

I'M FROM
Mugwort Essence

star rating

4.7

(1609)

favorite

813

upvote

11

comment

8

8 Comments

Iamvan user profile picture

Iamvan

Dry/Sensitive

The skin1004, technically speaking, is not 100% centella asiatica. It has other ingredients although mininal. This toner is more of a mild exfoliant geared for sensitive skin means it's skin friendly for everyone ( unless you have cica allergies ) The I'm from mugwort essence. This is more of a soothing and calming essence, again sensitive skin friendly. There's a marketing rule that if a certain ingredients reach a bare minimum of percentage it can be omitted from the ing. list ( you can look this up ) You can use both of this product in a certain routine, the toner first then the essence. You can pick the one that best suite what you're looking for, cause this 2 serves different purpose
upvote

2

comment

0

Patwreckkk user profile picture

Patwreckkk

Oily/Sensitive

Would u still recommend the Madagascar toner/Ampoule if i have 2 out of 6 in my routine that has centella in it?
Acne cream

Pyunkang Yul
Acne cream

star rating

4.8

(4)

favorite

27

Supple Preparation Unscented Toner

Dear, Klairs
Supple Preparation Unscented Toner

star rating

4.7

(769)

favorite

2186

upvote

0

comment

0

happyglowyskinlife user profile picture

happyglowyskinlife

Oily/Sensitive

I love both πŸ™ˆ there's a slight difference. They're both soothing ingredients, but Centella does help with acne-prone skin and mugwort not so much. Well, that's my experience with the ingredients. Mugwort is not used in Western skincare products, but Centella picked up the fame and is used not only in Kbeauty products, Western brands are using this baby too! So my recommendation is Centella Asiatica πŸ’šπŸŒΏπŸ’š
upvote

2

comment

0

Patwreckkk user profile picture

Patwreckkk

Oily/Sensitive

Would u still recommend the Madagascar toner/Ampoule if i have 2 out of 6 in my routine that has centella in it?
upvote

0

comment

0

nimiii user profile picture

nimiii

Dry/Sensitive

I would choose centella as I’ve had amazing experiences with it so far. it’s really helped my redness and spots, so I always recommend it. πŸ’—
upvote

1

comment

0

illie user profile picture

illie

Dry/Sensitive

I would pick centella, work great for me also has more studies than mugwort
upvote

1

comment

0

BonnieJean user profile picture

BonnieJean

Oily/Resilient

I've never really tried mugwort. I have had great experiences with centella products.
upvote

1

comment

0

Picky app preview

Join the Picky Community

The Picky community helps you discover new products through discussion boards, honest reviews, expert articles and redeemable free product rewards. #GetPicky!