AHA/BHA won't work on closed comedones | Skin Concern

Skin Concern

Shooky user profile picture

Shooky

Dry/Sensitive

dot15,147 Views

AHA/BHA won't work on closed comedones

So whenever I ask someone for recommendations on how to clear closed comedones or ccs, they always reply with using BHA or exfoliators. I have tried at least 4 different exfoliators, and none of them have worked even the slightest bit. Are there any other options? For those that successfully stopped their closed comedones, what product or routine did you do that made them disappear? Thanks for the help !
Mild

COSRX
Mild

star rating

4.2

(51)

favorite

132

Aloe BHA Skin Toner

BENTON
Aloe BHA Skin Toner

star rating

4.6

(858)

favorite

1046

COSRX AHA 7 Whitehead Power Liquid 100ml

COSRX
COSRX AHA 7 Whitehead Power Liquid 100ml

star rating

5.0

(1)

favorite

43

Sebo Pure Vegetal 3 in 1 Cleanser and Exfoliator

YVES ROCHER
Sebo Pure Vegetal 3 in 1 Cleanser and Exfoliator

star rating

4.6

(5)

favorite

5

upvote

51

comment

17

17 Comments

ElizaSunny user profile picture

ElizaSunny

Oily/Sensitive

Hello, the closed comedones may be caused by a product from your routine that's clogging the pores. Please revise other products from your routine or go to basics (cleanser, moisturizer and sunscreen) for a couple of weeks and see how your skin reacts.
upvote

4

comment

0

Shooky user profile picture

Shooky

Dry/Sensitive

I have actually gone back to basics. A non-comedogenic cleanser, the Benton BHA toner, and Innisfree Blueberry Moisturizer. Perhaps I just need to double cleanse. Thank you for replying!
upvote

1

comment

0

givemeglowyskin user profile picture

givemeglowyskin

Dry/Resilient

im experiencing the same issue too! been dealing witb cc for close to 2 years. its not completely clear, cc keep coming back. went to derm, they recommended me to use differin. but im afraid my skin might purge 🙃
upvote

2

comment

0

Shooky user profile picture

Shooky

Dry/Sensitive

is that a gel? I think they made me use it too, and it didn't work at all.
upvote

1

comment

0

X

xinxin

Oily/Sensitive

(essay ahead) that’s strange that the derms only recommended extractions rather than also giving you something topical (I’m no expert tho!) I can’t quite tell what the percentage of BHA in the cleanser is, but if it is low, you may want to give higher % BHA a try. The cosrx contains 7% AHA, which is quite normal for exfoliation. Or if you don’t want to go down the exfoliation route, you may try benzoyl peroxide, azaleic acid, or retinoids (like adapalene). If it’s severe, perhaps you can ask for prescription strength retinoids (like tretinoin or isotretinoin)? Here are some other factors that may contribute to acne/ closed comedones. 1. not enough hydration Dehydrated skin compensates by producing more oils (which can lead to acne). If this is your case, try adding in a hydrating toner or essence. 2. too much moisturization You could be using products that are too thick for your skin and clogging your pores, resulting in acne. Switch to a more lightweight/ less comedogenic moisturizer. These other tips may help with your oiliness. - oil cleansing/ double cleansing - use a product with niacinamide (helps with oil regulation)
upvote

2

comment

0

Shooky user profile picture

Shooky

Dry/Sensitive

I am definitely hydrated. From what I've read, I think I really need to consider double cleansing, and if that doesn't work, I'd try a higher concentration since all of my BHA products have low concentration. My dermatologist recommended me a topical gel, but she mentioned that it was to soften the comedones so she could extract it easier.
upvote

0

comment

0

givemeglowyskin user profile picture

givemeglowyskin

Dry/Resilient

yes! the derm prescribed differin gel to me! i didnt use it because i dont wanna experience purge 😅 as i feel my ccs aren't servere. but still using paulas choice bha 2% and other exfoliating products cant really help.
upvote

1

comment

0

Shooky user profile picture

Shooky

Dry/Sensitive

My ccs aren't severe either. I guess our situation is pretty similar 😓
upvote

0

comment

0

Picky app preview

Join the Picky Community

The Picky community helps you discover new products through discussion boards, honest reviews, expert articles and redeemable free product rewards. #GetPicky!