I swear by Garnier Micellar Cleansing Water Waterproof to remove my eye and face make up. For my waterproof mascara, I pour a little on a cotton pad an hold it for about a minute, and gently wipe. It ALL comes off. I also use it on my face to cleanse in the morning. I can feel a difference in how clean my face feels. ALSO, DO NOT FORGET TO SHAKE BEFORE USING!