Oil or balm?

I know a lot of us love a double cleanse in the evening. It's the best way to get all that makeup and oil and dirt and sunscreen off your face at the end of the day. But for that first cleanse, what's your preference between cleansing oil and cleansing balm? What are the benefits of each, do you think one is better than the other? Does each better suit a certain skin type or skin concern than others? I've only ever used a balm (the one attached here) but I'm curious about oils! Drop your favorites of each in the comments, I'd love to find some inspiration on what to try next!